White and gray remain the two most popular kitchen cabinet colors in Chicago, but choosing between them can feel overwhelming. Both offer clean, versatile backdrops for kitchen design, yet each creates a distinctly different atmosphere. This comparison breaks down the practical differences to help Chicago homeowners make the right choice for their specific kitchen.
The Popularity of Both Colors
White cabinets have dominated kitchen design for over two decades. Gray emerged as a major trend around 2015 and remains strong. Current Chicago market data shows:
- White cabinets: 55% of kitchen projects
- Gray cabinets: 25% of kitchen projects
- Natural wood: 15% of kitchen projects
- Other colors: 5% of kitchen projects
Both colors maintain strong resale appeal in the Chicago market. Neither choice is wrong from an investment perspective.
White Cabinet Advantages
White cabinets offer distinct benefits that explain their enduring popularity:
Timeless appeal: White kitchens have been popular for over a century and show no signs of dating. A white kitchen installed in 2026 will still look appropriate in 2046.
Space perception: White reflects light and makes kitchens appear larger and more open. This matters significantly in Chicago condos, bungalows, and vintage homes with smaller kitchen footprints.
Versatility: White works with virtually any countertop, backsplash, and flooring combination. Changing accent colors or hardware updates the look without repainting cabinets.
Light enhancement: Chicago winters are gray and long. White cabinets maximize available natural light, making kitchens feel brighter during dark months.
Broad buyer appeal: White kitchens appeal to the widest range of buyers. For homeowners planning to sell within 5-10 years, white remains the safest choice.
White Cabinet Disadvantages
White comes with practical challenges:
Shows everything: Dirt, grease, fingerprints, and wear show immediately on white surfaces. Families with young children find white cabinets require constant cleaning.
Can feel cold: Stark white in a north-facing kitchen can feel clinical and cold. Warm whites help, but the cool factor remains compared to warmer colors.
Ubiquity: White kitchens are everywhere. Homeowners wanting distinctive spaces may find white feels generic.
Staining risk: White cabinets near stoves can yellow over time from cooking oils and heat. Quality finishes resist this better than cheap paint.
Gray Cabinet Advantages
Gray offers a contemporary alternative with its own strengths:
Modern sophistication: Gray reads as current and stylish. It signals design awareness without being trendy or risky.
Hides wear better: Fingerprints, minor scuffs, and everyday wear are less visible on gray surfaces. Practical for busy households.
Warmth options: Gray ranges from cool blue-grays to warm greiges. Warm gray tones add coziness that white cannot achieve.
Design flexibility: Gray pairs beautifully with white countertops, wood tones, brass hardware, and colorful accents. It serves as a sophisticated neutral.
Stands out appropriately: Gray feels distinctive without being bold. It offers personality while maintaining broad appeal.
.png)
Gray Cabinet Disadvantages
Gray presents its own challenges:
Trend timing: Gray surged in popularity around 2015-2020. While still popular, some designers consider it past peak. Cool blue-grays especially feel dated compared to warm grays.
Can feel dark: Gray absorbs more light than white. In smaller kitchens or north-facing rooms, gray can make spaces feel smaller and darker.
Undertone complexity: Gray is notoriously difficult to select. Colors that look perfect in the showroom can read blue, purple, or green in different lighting. Sample extensively before committing.
Narrower combinations: Gray limits countertop and backsplash options more than white. Certain stone colors clash with gray undertones.
Need expert advice? Call (224) 808-5100 for free consultation and measurement.
Chicago-Specific Considerations
Local factors influence the white vs gray decision:
Natural light availability: North-facing kitchens and basement-level garden units common in Chicago benefit from white. South-facing kitchens with abundant light can handle gray successfully.
Architectural style: White suits Chicago bungalows, Victorian greystones, and classic six-flats. Gray works well in contemporary condos and modern renovations.
Existing elements: Chicago homes often have features that cannot change easily. Consider fixed elements like brick, hardwood floors, and trim colors when choosing cabinet color.
Neighborhood expectations: Lincoln Park and North Shore buyers expect certain aesthetics. Understanding local market preferences matters for resale value.
Choosing the Right White
Not all whites are equal. Selecting the right white prevents cold or yellowed results:
Warm whites: Benjamin Moore White Dove, Simply White, Chantilly Lace. These have subtle yellow or cream undertones that feel inviting.
Cool whites: Benjamin Moore Decorator's White, Super White. These have blue undertones that feel crisp and modern.
For most Chicago homes with warm wood floors and traditional architecture, warm whites perform better. Cool whites work in contemporary spaces with cool-toned flooring.
Always test paint samples in your actual kitchen, observing at different times of day. Showroom lighting differs dramatically from home lighting.
Choosing the Right Gray
Gray selection requires even more care due to undertone complexity:
Warm grays (greige): Benjamin Moore Revere Pewter, Sherwin-Williams Agreeable Gray. These have brown undertones that feel cozy.
Cool grays: Benjamin Moore Stonington Gray, Sherwin-Williams Repose Gray. These have blue or purple undertones that feel modern.
True grays: Benjamin Moore Chelsea Gray, Sherwin-Williams Dorian Gray. Balanced undertones that read as pure gray.
The same gray can look completely different based on lighting, flooring, and adjacent colors. Order large samples and live with them for several days before deciding.
Two-Tone Option
Many Chicago homeowners avoid choosing by using both colors:
- White uppers with gray island
- White uppers with gray lowers
- White perimeter with gray island
- Gray base cabinets with white uppers
Two-tone kitchens add visual interest and allow enjoying benefits of both colors. This approach has grown from 15% of projects five years ago to over 30% today.
The key to successful two-tone design is sufficient contrast. Pairing a warm white with a light warm gray creates muddy results. Distinct colors that clearly differ work better.
What Chicago Designers Recommend
Local kitchen designers share current guidance:
For small kitchens: White remains the strongest recommendation. The space-expanding effect outweighs other considerations in tight Chicago kitchens.
For large kitchens: Either works well. Gray adds warmth and interest to spacious kitchens where white might feel sterile.
For resale priority: White for broadest appeal, warm gray for design-conscious buyers.
For personal homes: Choose what you love. Living with a color you dislike to satisfy future buyers makes no sense for long-term homeowners.
For indecisive clients: Two-tone provides best of both worlds.
Making the Final Decision
Consider these questions when deciding:
- How much natural light does your kitchen receive?
- How important is hiding everyday wear and fingerprints?
- Are you planning to sell within 5 years?
- Do you prefer warm or cool color temperatures?
- What countertop and backsplash materials are you considering?
- How long do you want cabinets to feel current?
There is no universally correct answer. Both white and gray are excellent choices that serve Chicago homeowners well when selected thoughtfully for specific conditions.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Are gray kitchen cabinets going out of style?
A: Cool blue-gray cabinets are declining, but warm grays remain popular. The trend is shifting toward warmer undertones rather than abandoning gray entirely. Quality warm gray cabinets will remain stylish for years.
Q: Do white cabinets make a kitchen look bigger?
A: Yes. White reflects light and creates visual expansion that makes kitchens appear larger and more open. This effect is significant in smaller Chicago kitchens and north-facing rooms with limited natural light.
Q: Which is easier to keep clean, white or gray cabinets?
A: Gray cabinets hide fingerprints, minor scuffs, and everyday wear better than white. White shows everything immediately. For busy families with children, gray offers practical advantages.
Q: Can I mix white and gray cabinets in the same kitchen?
A: Yes, two-tone kitchens are increasingly popular. Common combinations include white uppers with gray lowers or white perimeter cabinets with a gray island. Ensure sufficient contrast between the two colors.
Q: What color countertops go with gray cabinets?
A: White and light countertops (white quartz, marble, light granite) pair beautifully with gray cabinets. Avoid countertops with undertones that clash with your specific gray. Test samples together before committing.
Get Started
Choosing between white and gray cabinets comes down to personal preference, kitchen conditions, and lifestyle factors. Both colors offer excellent long-term value and design flexibility.
AK Cabinet Craft showrooms display both white and gray cabinet options in various styles. Seeing colors in person and discussing your specific kitchen helps clarify the right choice.
Schedule Your Free Consultation:
- Call: (224) 808-5100
- Visit: Lincoln Park or Bucktown showroom
- Online: akcabinetcraft.com/contacts
